test

Dinner served in a old plantation house. Decor was pleasant. Service was good but not the greatest. The lighting was... read moreDinner served in a old plantation house. Decor was pleasant. Service was good but not the greatest. The lighting was very dim. Saw a woman eating her food by flashlight. All in all, it was a wonderful fine dining experience. read less

1/04/2021

The restaurant is in a wonderful spot and great for a pre dinner drink on the beach. All of our... read moreThe restaurant is in a wonderful spot and great for a pre dinner drink on the beach. All of our food was superb and good portions . Our waitress was very helpful and knowledgeable, we will definitely return next time we are in Islamorada . read less

1/01/2021

Don’t expect to see your server after he had taken your order. We had to get the attention of another... read moreDon’t expect to see your server after he had taken your order. We had to get the attention of another server to bring pepper to our table which arrived after 3/4 of the meal was eaten.Don’t expect the wine you to arrive when dinner arrives- you need to get the attention of someone to bring it. Don’t expect a wine chiller to arrive with the white wine you ordered-again we had to get the attention of another waiter to bring a chiller. You are then on your own filling your wine glasses.
Short ribs and scallop dish was over cooked. We had made another reservation to return Pierres later this week but based on our experience we will not be returning. read less

11/27/2020

I made a reservation for Thanksgiving for the 5 of us back in October. When we arrived in Islamorada I... read moreI made a reservation for Thanksgiving for the 5 of us back in October. When we arrived in Islamorada I called to confirm and they told me they didn’t have our reservation but they would check and call me back. The first girl said “the other girl doesn’t always put things in the computer. “ Well nobody called me back so when I followed up the “manager” said “parties of 6 or more had to leave a credit card deposit so they cancelled our reservation .” Well first we were 5 and secondly nobody asked me for a card- which I gladly would have provided. Now it is Thanksgiving Andre have no place to eat. Thanks Pierre’s for ruining a special time for us! read less

11/26/2020

We were staying at Cheeca but had my birthday dinner at Pierre's. The cheese and charcutiere platter appetizer was outstanding.... read moreWe were staying at Cheeca but had my birthday dinner at Pierre's. The cheese and charcutiere platter appetizer was outstanding. Wonderful service. My fish was a little over cooked but delicious. We are returning for my wife's birthday next week. Also purchased a gift certificate for a co-workers birthday so she and her husband could experience a memorable dinner. read less

11/25/2020

wanted to eat inside with fine dining. Tired of outdoor bar food and Jimmy Buffet music On line menu looked... read morewanted to eat inside with fine dining. Tired of outdoor bar food and Jimmy Buffet music On line menu looked great . Plenty of our favorite French dishes. Went inside and took elevator to second floor. Decor and ambiance wonderful French Moroccan
Service very attentive . Ordered Aperol Spritz for wife dirty martini up for me Looked at menue and was not what was on web site. No onion soup What French restaurant doesnt have onion soup? No steak tartar, no sweet breads. Nothing on menue turned us on. Specials were two fish dishes again no thanks, venison which sounded good until i was told $ 60 and some kind of steak for $90. Settled on Charcuterie for $ 30 a plate of thinly sliced cold cuts. Left $75 poorer. Ive eaten in the finest in San Francisco, Chicago, N Y and Paris. This doesnt campare read less

11/19/2020

Food caliber was average and extremely overpriced. Key lime pie looked like it was purchased from local grocery store. Also... read moreFood caliber was average and extremely overpriced. Key lime pie looked like it was purchased from local grocery store. Also we were jammed together outside when there was plenty of room to provide social distancing. read less

11/14/2020

We went to this restaurant because we are huge fans of Bloodline. So glad we did! Dinner was fantastic. Exceptional... read moreWe went to this restaurant because we are huge fans of Bloodline. So glad we did! Dinner was fantastic. Exceptional service, and the view was amazing! read less

11/05/2020

We had booked a table but arrived early and had a drink on the back patio and ended up ordering... read moreWe had booked a table but arrived early and had a drink on the back patio and ended up ordering from there so we could enjoy the table outside and beach view. Excellent bar service with a fantastic off the cuff cocktail. Our favorite dinner of the week, get the burger! read less

11/02/2020

I went to this restaurant with my family of 4. We were impressed by the atmosphere and food, which was... read moreI went to this restaurant with my family of 4. We were impressed by the atmosphere and food, which was all very nice. We had the burger, ahi tuna, and 2 fish dishes. All dishes were perfect, except my fish was a little chewy.

It would be 5 stars, but I took a star away due to the bad service we got. Our waiter seemed very snooty and rude to us, especially when we couldn’t pronounce the French items on the menu, asked any questions, and declined any appetizers or desserts.
We were dressed more casually and brought our child, who is very well behaved, however the waiter seemed very unfriendly and terse towards us. Our family dines mostly at finer establishments, and have never felt looked down upon by other waiters, except at this restaurant. The waiter also had a long list of specials and items not listed on the menu that he recited verbally with thick accent, which I am not a fan of as it is too hard to remember. When I asked him to repeat himself, he seemed in a bad mood. The rest of the wait staff seemed nice but we were not comfortable with our waiter. He never smiled or seemed very enthusiastic or happy to be at work at all.
I would definitely return to Pierre’s but hope for a better, and more friendly wait staff, and menu items to actually be written on the menu. read less

10/12/2020

The food was good but overpriced. Service was excellent. However, I had a hard time getting past the slamming door... read moreThe food was good but overpriced. Service was excellent. However, I had a hard time getting past the slamming door to the patio. Every time the wait staff went between the interior and exterior seating ( every 30-40 seconds) the door slammed loudly and vibrated the whole interior. The low lighting and soft music was not enough to compensate for this. read less

10/05/2020

As I walked into the beautiful large Key West Style two story restaurant a lovely hostess showed. E up the... read moreAs I walked into the beautiful large Key West Style two story restaurant a lovely hostess showed. E up the sweeping wooden staircase to the second floor balcony overlooking the beautiful property and the Bay
As I sat in my chair Ella Fitzgerald’s “I Love Paris “ flavored the atmosphere for an exceptional culinary experience
The service was second to none
I had raw oysters from Washington State as well as Massachusetts. The Pacific oysters were a delicious Briny flavor while the Massachusetts oysters were fantastically succulent
Tge chef prepared for me a Pork Belly appetizer that was extremely flavorful and delicate
I then had caviar with Moët Chandon Brut which was
superb
For an entree I had the Grouper prepared grilled , tender and juicy with French string beans and rice pilaf was high was extraordinary
For dessert had the home made Key alone Pue which exceeded any previous Key Lomé pie experience

A must restaurant for the discerning diner

Dr Chris O read less

10/02/2020

My sister and I went to Pierre’s to watch sunset and decided to go inside after and eat at the... read moreMy sister and I went to Pierre’s to watch sunset and decided to go inside after and eat at the bar. Our bartender, Claire, was very knowledgeable about the menu and offered recommendations. We had the French onion soup and Kobe burger- it was one of the best burgers I’ve ever had! Claire made a few different cocktails, the expresso martini being one of her specialties! Claire’s personality and attentiveness made us feel very welcome and we had a great time talking to her and learning more about the town (she’s a local). We will definitely go back to sit at the bar with Claire! Thanks for the great service, we had a blast! read less

10/01/2020

Views were AMAZING. Inside so sophisticated and swanky. Our server Joshua was outstanding and went above and beyond. Knowledgeable in... read moreViews were AMAZING. Inside so sophisticated and swanky. Our server Joshua was outstanding and went above and beyond. Knowledgeable in drinks and food items. Took pics for us. Made our stay comfortable. What a great guy.

Highly highly recommend this spot. read less

9/22/2020

Great dishes, fine wines and very professional service. The setting is beautiful both inside and in the porch. It's a... read moreGreat dishes, fine wines and very professional service. The setting is beautiful both inside and in the porch. It's a very upscale restaurant offering an overall great experience. read less

3/20/2020