test

Allen R.

Fine dining great food with impeccable service. The whole experience is one of elegance wonderful ambiance great experience. The trip... read more to Pierre’s made my wife’s 50th birthday a elegant unforgettable night. The trip to Pierre’s was the height of our Islamorada weekend.

6/18/2018

Cassandra C.

We had a wonderful dinner at Pierre’s. My husband had the fresh catch and I had the seafood curry. Best... read more meal by far on our trip to the Florida Keys. Our server was Ashley I believe. She was a lot of fun and very attentive. We also finished off our meal with the dulce de leche crepes. Yummy!!! Restaurant and the resort has great ambiance. Give it a try!

6/17/2018

michaelnti

Very impressed, great views, great service and awesome food. We had a Watermelon & Barrata Salad that was unreal, Filet... read more Mignonette Steak and the nights special Lobster Thermidor. Fabulous and fancy.

5/30/2018

Chef2112

Well when it come to “fine Dining” in Islamorada there is little else to touch the venue,location and service of... read more this restaurant.
We booked a table by phone with Sandra the day before our anniversary dinner and found her to be extremely professional and helpful with no difficulty in understanding my English accent or our requirements which can not be said for a number of restaurants in the area.
Sandra then met us on the evening and gave us a choice of tables.
Wine list choice was good and pricing reasonable for this area. My only minor complaint was the quality of the actual food menus (not the food on them) but the style and condition of the menus being something found a roadside bar or diner.
Daily specials very good

Overall good meal experience

5/26/2018

Deb S.

We enjoyed Pierre's on 2 nights. 1st visit was to the bar on the lower level which is beautifully appointed.... read more The guys stayed inside and the girls went outside on the veranda to watch the sunset. Pierre makes a mean cocktail. We enjoyed it so much that we came back for dinner and sat at a table outside on the upper veranda. The hotel is decorated in a West Indies style - it is very comfortable. Service was attentive and the manager came and checked on our meal. We had the bone in filet mignon and the lobster curry. There was nothing left by the end of the meal. Dress code is a bit all over the map but I was comfortable wearing palazzo pants and Joe had a dressy Hawaiian shirt with slacks.

5/22/2018

Mariota C.

Had the most delicious dinner - they did not mind us having 2 entrees and we were not hungry followed... read more by pudding. Service very attentive.

5/17/2018

Tony S.

In a beautiful place with a stunning view sat on the veranda as the sun sets. Had read mixed reviews... read more but can honestly say the food was outstanding! The only gripes was one of our party is a vegetarian and the choice is very poor, the other is the price. It’s extremely and I mean extremely expensive, as this was our special wedding meal I didn’t care but I probably wouldn’t make a return visit based on the prices alone.

5/15/2018

foodie-travelor

My husband and I, along with Clients, family and friends, have spend thousands of dollars dining at this restaurant for... read more years. We were recently dining with 3 additional couples, business associates and close friends. The service was unforgiveable, the timing of the meal was beyond unforgiveable. The treatment we received when trying to rectify the situation with management was enough to make me write this review. Never have a group been so completely dissatisfied with a dining experience. The food, my compliments to the chef and kitchen, the only saving grace of our entire evening. Alas, we will not return...it's the end of an era for GrayBlackBook!

5/11/2018

Cheri K.

We dined upstairs at Pierre's and it was a beautiful setting. Most of the staff was friendly and helpful. Our... read more waitress did not seem very interested in our experience and actually forgot to put in an order for one of our friends, she got her...

5/08/2018

Daniela C.

We had the most amazing experience at Pierre's! Exquisite food combined with a beautiful setting, few in the Keys can... read more compare. We were temped to start with oysters, an array of 3 types served with house made cocktail jam and mignonette. I can't decide is...

5/05/2018

livingaimfully

If you want a special and romantic night out in the keys this is the place. You will have to... read more dress up and spend a bunch of money but it is worth it. I would not go there with kids- they treat you differently even though my kids were angels. The seafood curry is a must and the beef carpaccio as well.

4/29/2018

suedrzewiecki

The kitchen really did a great job. Our waiter was not around and didn’t seem to be interested. He needs... read more some serious training.

4/14/2018

bandcquick87

Beautiful restaurant, wonderful food and excellent service. Be sure to sit where you can enjoy the sunset.

4/12/2018

PattiL2011

We were very pleased with our choice of Pierre’s. We sat on the balcony and had the very best view... read more possible. Had the crab stuffed lobster, large serving, started with onion soup and endive salad, really tasty! Good service, good wine list (we had Lytton Springs Zin). Was it expensive, yes but we enjoyed it all!

4/11/2018

CL M.

The restaurant is a lovely colonial style building with curious Indian accent interiors. We had an outside table on the... read more balcony overlooking the Gulf so a quite magnificent sunset. Food was beautifully fresh and nicely presented. We had the seafood tower to share which was great and then lobster and yellowtail, both beautifully presented. I notice there's not much use of dedicated garlic flavours in the places and as a Brit I miss it with the lovely fresh seafood. We didn't make cheap choices so our bill was high but what we expected. Service was pleasant but on occasion a little inattentive (needed reminding for a drinks order for example) but nothing that spoiled a really lovely meal.

4/10/2018