test

We knew it would be pricey, but it was our 50th anniversary. Our evening was well worth it. Escargot was... read moreWe knew it would be pricey, but it was our 50th anniversary. Our evening was well worth it. Escargot was clearly the best we’ve ever had. Same for the Key Lime dessert. I had scallops; again, perfectly prepared.
All the staff was personable and well trained. Congratulations to the owners who put this all together.
CH read less

6/21/2021

This was our favorite dinner in Islamorada. The setting is lovely, and the food was delicious. Everyone in our party... read moreThis was our favorite dinner in Islamorada. The setting is lovely, and the food was delicious. Everyone in our party loved their meal. Also, the sunsets from the porch are beautiful! read less

6/09/2021

Pierre’s is a beautiful restaurant on Morado Bay. The food, drinks and service were top notch. The sunset views from... read morePierre’s is a beautiful restaurant on Morado Bay. The food, drinks and service were top notch. The sunset views from the top balcony were incredible. Our dinner at Pierre’s was so memorable and one of our favorites on our trip. Can’t wait to visit again. read less

6/06/2021

Went for a bday.
Asked for front row an keven was great in getting it for us.
Food was terrific.
Very romantic

6/02/2021

This my 4th visit to Pierre's over about as many years. We occasionally spend a long weekend in the Upper... read moreThis my 4th visit to Pierre's over about as many years. We occasionally spend a long weekend in the Upper Keys, from Miami. We have had consistently good food each time and the setting is beautiful, located on a little inlet/ bay with sand. It is more elegant than the setting suggest and is perfect for a romantic night or a solid good quality meal. This time we visited while on Memorial Day weekend. I started with the octopus and it was solid, not gooey and had an almost crispy texture. I followed with the duck, which was rich and cooked perfectly. My wife had the Chilean Sea bass over a puree of artichoke, which was the special...and special it was. The fish was fresh and meaty, but delicate in flavor and the puree was indescribably subtle and perfect texture. We also tasted the escargot in a voulevant pastry which was as flaky and decadent as the escargot were rich and tasty. The shrimp was good as well, not overdone, as can be the case. The dessert selection which we sampled included the key lime tart, creamy but light in a thick flavorful graham cracker crust, a dulce de leche cheese cake, also very rich, but not too sweet, and the creme brulee which was the best of the three with a smooth delicious pudding covered with a crispy brittle caramel crust. We did take our own wine, and the corkage fee was quite steep, especially for the Keys ($50). But, I saved the best comments for the last. Our server, Ellen Grace, was attentive and on top of every detail. She knew each dish down to the smallest detail, at one point going back to the kitchen to inquire about the pastry because she wanted/needed to get it right. Such professionalism in a server is hard to find and a mark of an excellent restaurant and its attention to detail. We will return again and look for Ellen Grace for another amazing dining experience. read less

5/31/2021

This place is amazing from the friendliness of the staff to the awesome service and especially the food. The food... read moreThis place is amazing from the friendliness of the staff to the awesome service and especially the food. The food was amazing good. I had the prime rib which was amazing and my wife had octopus and she said it was delicious. One of our family members had scallops and he said the were awesome. Our waitress was great and our key lime pie was freshly made and delicious. Highly recommend. read less

5/30/2021

I’m a part-time resident of Islamorada. I’ve been to peers maybe 15 times in the last eight years. I’ve always... read moreI’m a part-time resident of Islamorada. I’ve been to peers maybe 15 times in the last eight years. I’ve always enjoyed the view the bar the beach out back the food has always been pretty good and the service usually fine. I went back last night for the first time with the new management and I highly doubt i’ll be back there again this year. As always the location is spot on and the service was more like being at a banquet where everything was timed with the motive of turning tables. The price point for Pierres is way out of of line. I don’t mind spending good money on good food but this was over the top. The food is not as good as it used to be and certainly does not reflect the price point. There are way better places in town to eat at but I will go back and sit at the bar and watch the sunset. read less

5/29/2021

Went to this restaurant to celebrate our anniversary expecting a classy experience. Pierre's does not deliver! Food is not great,... read moreWent to this restaurant to celebrate our anniversary expecting a classy experience. Pierre's does not deliver! Food is not great, ambience missing and place just looks deteriorated. The waiter staff is very good, but you are paying a couple hundred dollars for a couple and it's just not worth it. read less

5/22/2021

Eat at Pierre's 23 times over last 14 years. It was always near 5 star until we dined there May... read moreEat at Pierre's 23 times over last 14 years. It was always near 5 star until we dined there May 11. The Bar as always was great. However the dining upstairs had radically deteriorated. A party of 5 , three people did not eat their entree. Food was unacceptable. Don't know why but several locals at our hotel reported the same experience. Go there for a drink but avoid dining. All of us had eaten there for years but will not go back. Very sad read less

5/15/2021

I thought I would be in my happy place at Pierre's when I scored a place in the bar by... read moreI thought I would be in my happy place at Pierre's when I scored a place in the bar by the window. They have amazing views and it appeared they had a great wine list and menu. First let me tell you their menu is very pricey! Which I have no problem paying for good food and service. I knew I was in trouble when I asked if the French sparkling rose was sweet and he answered; "I don't know I have never tried it". There was an awkward silence as I waited for him to offer to find out. Nothing... so I ordered it. The sparkling was lovely so I gave the server feedback on its characteristics.
For food I started out with the French Onion soup, a classic right??? The broth was good but I literally had two strands of onion in the entire ONION soup. I decided to cut my losses and leave. Just another example of a restaurant relying on its views to draw people. read less

5/15/2021

We have lived in Miami for 16 years and have been to Pierre’s every year or two for 14 years.... read moreWe have lived in Miami for 16 years and have been to Pierre’s every year or two for 14 years. I have up until this evening said it was the best restaurant in S. Florida. That says a lot considering we have lived in NY City for 20 years and London for two years.

We have mostly come for an Anniversary or Birthday, Tonight we went to Pierre’s for our 33rd Wedding Anniversary. While the food was good, the rest of the experience was a disappointment. The menu was limited and the prices through the roof. Although they knew it was our Anniversary, they did nothing special for us. Most restaurants of this caliber give you a dessert or glass of champagne as a courtesy. Pierre’s has done this in the past and other restaurants have made a special event, Special. Not Pierre’s.

I can no longer recommend Pierre’s restaurant and write this in the hope that things change and the restaurant goes back to what it once was. read less

4/27/2021

We went to Pierres two nights in a row during our spring break vacation. The first night was with a... read moreWe went to Pierres two nights in a row during our spring break vacation. The first night was with a reservation we made in advance and we were given a beautiful table overlooking the water on the upper veranda. The next night we wanted to go back but we didn’t have a reservation, so we tried our luck at finding a seat on the beach in front and eating from the bar menu. We were lucky and had a wonderful experience twice. I left one of my cherished jackets at the restaurant and didn’t realize it until we left Islamorada. One of the managers, Sandra, was kind enough to take the time to mail my jacket back to me even though it was one of the busiest times of the year for the restaurant. Beautiful food, setting, sunset and lovely people. read less

4/21/2021

We had planned to sit outside but the late April sun still shone too hot so we opted for the... read moreWe had planned to sit outside but the late April sun still shone too hot so we opted for the couch at the far side of Pierre's bar, beneath the canoe artfully perched on the wall. The drinks were varied and sublime but soon it was time to move upstairs to the balcony for our dinner. The sun shades adjusted to keep the heat down, we settled in for one more cocktail, and a bottle of Shafer cab. The onion soup? Excellent and hot enough to make me forget the sun. The foie gras? My table mates raved. It's not pate, it's the actual liver so you're getting the real thing. If you're unfamiliar with sous vide cooking, learn how the experts do it by ordering the veal cheeks. Triple tail was on the menu so two of us ventured there to great acclaim. The place is expensive but they deliver value. As the sun set, the shades went up, the breeze came alive and the view through the palms made the setting perfect. I'm hard to impress. I was impressed. My only regret? The party of four celebrating a birthday at an adjacent table failed to offer us a slice of their cake even though we sang along. Oh, well. read less

4/19/2021

From its fantastic location to its beautiful building to its excellent service to its exceptional cocktails to its sublime and... read moreFrom its fantastic location to its beautiful building to its excellent service to its exceptional cocktails to its sublime and amazing food, a must for anyone looking for a fine dining experience in the Keys. read less

4/13/2021

We went on Easter. They had a fixed menu with three entrees for a set price of $120 each. This... read moreWe went on Easter. They had a fixed menu with three entrees for a set price of $120 each. This wasn’t advertised even they confirmed that. When asked if we can order from their regular menu the answer was this is the only menu. Gratuity was included although it was scratched out on the receipt. We had two kids with us and although they had a kids menu it wasn’t offered to us. Probably because the waitress wanted the $240 for the kids so her tip that was included would be much higher than if she had given us the kids menu. The food was ok at best. The table behind us was obnoxious loud fighting, crying, using foul language. The waitress didn’t offer to move us or them. When asked about the tip being scratched out that was by mistake. They are trying to take advantage of people on vacation knowing they won’t be coming back. I called three times asking for a manager to call me. No one has. Please don’t fall in the same trap we did. read less

4/13/2021