test

Great dishes, fine wines and very professional service. The setting is beautiful both inside and in the porch. It's a... read moreGreat dishes, fine wines and very professional service. The setting is beautiful both inside and in the porch. It's a very upscale restaurant offering an overall great experience. read less

3/20/2020

My wife and I went for dinner to celebrate her birthday. It was BEYOND all expectations!! The server was knowledgeable,... read moreMy wife and I went for dinner to celebrate her birthday. It was BEYOND all expectations!! The server was knowledgeable, super efficient and charming. The atmosphere- well how can you top sunset on the upper deck of a stunning old mansion? And the food - THE BEST!!! We enjoyed a lobster curry and a Delmonico steak. Both were simply perfect. For appetizers the raw trio was sumptuous. And for dessert, because we were in the Keys, key lime tarts! This was a top 10 meal for me, EVER! I can’t recall the last time I enjoyed a meal that much. read less

3/19/2020

We took a drive up highway 1 from Key West to explore and a friend suggested we stop here. We... read moreWe took a drive up highway 1 from Key West to explore and a friend suggested we stop here. We totally lucked out by being there literally when they opened at 5:30 officially at 6:00.
There is a gorgeous private beach area and veranda where you can enjoy a cocktail outside and we scored a table on the outside veranda at sunset,
Aside from the chill music, gorgeous setting, and professional staff, the food was out of this world.
My husband had the fish meunière if the day which happened to be grouped. He opted to add the crab leg and they take it out of the leg for you,
I had the vegan cauliflower dish with succotash and it was amazing!
The grilled octopus appetizer was equally terrific.
We decided to finish our wine in the Veranda which was no problem, I could have stayed all evening sitting there looking at the water,
You will love the whole experience, best to make reservations a few weeks in advance, read less

2/16/2020

This was the perfect place for celebrating my birthday and retirement! We sat on the porch with a view of... read moreThis was the perfect place for celebrating my birthday and retirement! We sat on the porch with a view of the sunset and beach. EVERYTHING was excellent from the cocktails to the dessert. Our waiter was professional, helpful and engaging- we discovered he grew up near where we are from! If you have a special occasion this is your place- you won’t be disappointed . read less

2/13/2020

Wahou !!! Deserve for sure the excellence price 2020 for everything ( service , food quality , decor , atmosphere... read moreWahou !!! Deserve for sure the excellence price 2020 for everything ( service , food quality , decor , atmosphere .... ) the GM David took very good care of us with a sense of detail that I have rarely seen before . The food quality was just right , the atmosphere was magic and the staff hyper professional . Please stop by anytime . read less

2/10/2020

Best restaurant. Amazing food, beautiful ambiance, spectacular service. From the duck eaters to the vegans- every one of the 14... read moreBest restaurant. Amazing food, beautiful ambiance, spectacular service. From the duck eaters to the vegans- every one of the 14 people at our table raved about their meal and experience. Highly recommend! read less

2/09/2020

Outstanding in every way! This is a splurge, but well worth it. Celebrated my birthday with family and friends and... read moreOutstanding in every way! This is a splurge, but well worth it. Celebrated my birthday with family and friends and everyone was blown away! Excellent service from Dawn who was very attentive and knowledgeable. The entire staff helped make this occasion very special. Thank you!!!
We ordered the seafood tower which was amazing, grilled octopus, maybe the best I’ve ever had, most of us ordered the catch of the day which was grouper. Outstanding! read less

2/08/2020

From greeting to good night Pierre’s was exceptional.
From cocktails on the veranda to exceptional service, along with wonderful appetizers and... read moreFrom greeting to good night Pierre’s was exceptional.
From cocktails on the veranda to exceptional service, along with wonderful appetizers and entrees, then retiring again to the veranda for coffee, my wife and I are totally impressed.
Pricey as others have mentioned but if yow want a nice evening and a great dining experience you need to do Pierre’s at least once.
Putting on my list to return next time we are in the Keys. read less

2/04/2020

Location is important, but they have gone above and beyond. The views, the candles, the upper porch, the service, the... read moreLocation is important, but they have gone above and beyond. The views, the candles, the upper porch, the service, the food..... all of it was amazing. A perfect date night, special occasion dinner, or vacation upscale (so many casual places in the keys that it was nice to have a more upscale place to dine)- Pierre's is the choice! Kind waiter, great service, delicious choices- just a fantastic restaurant! read less

1/31/2020

Unbelievable food and service. Melanie may be the best ever!
Grouper perfect.
Key lime tart a wonderful finish.
Looking forward... read moreUnbelievable food and service. Melanie may be the best ever!
Grouper perfect.
Key lime tart a wonderful finish.
Looking forward to our next visit! read less

1/23/2020

Our experience at Pierre’s was so magical that we returned to the bar every evening. Joshua made our time at... read moreOur experience at Pierre’s was so magical that we returned to the bar every evening. Joshua made our time at Pierre’s memorable. He’s charming, attentive and a world-class bartender. Highly recommend the cucumber martini but all the drinks were perfectly mixed. Oh yes, the food is delicious, too! Make sure you go to the bar on the main floor and if the weather permits walk on outside to the sand beach and enjoy the beautiful waterfront setting. You won’t regret it! read less

1/20/2020

Beautiful venue. Hostess accommodated our seating requests. Waitress Melanie was excellent and even set us up on the Veranda when... read moreBeautiful venue. Hostess accommodated our seating requests. Waitress Melanie was excellent and even set us up on the Veranda when a table came available for dessert after dining inside. Appetizers are overpriced in my opinion. Mains are pricey by Keys’ standards comparable to NYC metro area prices. Everyone in our group of 7 enjoyed our meals. read less

1/19/2020

There are lots of spots to get great food, at Pierre's we had outstanding service at both visits, making this... read moreThere are lots of spots to get great food, at Pierre's we had outstanding service at both visits, making this a step above. We were at the 9:30 new year's eve seating. what could have been a less-than-stellar experience ended up being a really nice night. I think that logistically, there were a lot of people moving around about the time we got there at 8:45, making it feel less special and intimate than we thought, given the pricetag. We wanted to check out the beach and the lovely building, but opted not to wander too far. There was security to get into the restaurant/beach area and more security to get into the restaurant, all monitored by colored wrist bands. There was nothing keeping us from moving around, we simply didn't know the area and opted to stay close so that we could be seated on time. The earlier seating was trying to leave as our seating was arriving, and all in a small foyer, so a little chaotic. However, once we got upstairs to our table, overlooking the beach, all was wonderful. Our server, Dawn, couldn't have been more wonderful or accommodating to our food allergies, etc. (there was not a choice for the meal, and it wasn't announced beforehand, so we needed some help making adjustments based on allergies) We both enjoyed our meals, watched the fireworks from the balcony over dessert and enjoyed chatting with a few other diners. We'd heard such good things about the food from locals, we wanted to give the restaurant another try, to choose our own meals and see how we did. Everything was wonderful and luckily, we had Dawn the next night! We found the wine menu to give us plenty to choose from, both our meals were quite good and of course, don't miss dessert! read less

1/13/2020

Way overrated! We made a reservation at Pierre's restaurant. We had the first seating at 6:00. The cost was $120... read moreWay overrated! We made a reservation at Pierre's restaurant. We had the first seating at 6:00. The cost was $120 pp. The food was good, but the portions were tiny. I was traveling with my extended 16-member family. The ages ranged from 20-80 years old. This elegant dining was good for my parents and me, but the 20 year old people did not eat. The price included entrance to the New Year's beach party. That was a lot of fun - live music, fireworks, parades & dancing. The $120 did not include any hats or noise makers for ringing in the new year.
I wish they had posted more information about tickets for just their beach party. We saw what looked like to be a whole other dining experience on the beach. That would have been more appropriate for the age group I was traveling with. When I called for reservations, I was not told about any other options.
Pierre's itself is lovely - just not what I was expecting for what we paid. read less

1/09/2020

The restaurant was nice and the food was good. It was more expensive than it was worth. The thing that... read moreThe restaurant was nice and the food was good. It was more expensive than it was worth. The thing that made the experience poor was our waiter. He had a European accent (maybe french or Italian) and was very suboptimal with a poor and snotty attitude. He took drink orders from the two parents but rushed off, ignoring the adult kids present. He then returned and one of the kids said he would like a beer. Instead of asking if any of the others wanted a drink, he again rushed off. When he next returned, another person and the other two parents that had arrived requested drinks. He seemed ticked off and told us to please give him all our drink orders. His service and attitude did not improve and ruined the experience, which should have been much better, given the high price we paid for dinner ($1500 for ten of us with 2 bottles of wine). I do not mind paying for a nice dinner, however the food, service, and ambiance should be commensurate with the price. And it just was not. Our family is in the restaurant business and we would not have this type of server in our place. read less

1/05/2020