test

We went to Pierres two nights in a row during our spring break vacation. The first night was with a... read moreWe went to Pierres two nights in a row during our spring break vacation. The first night was with a reservation we made in advance and we were given a beautiful table overlooking the water on the upper veranda. The next night we wanted to go back but we didn’t have a reservation, so we tried our luck at finding a seat on the beach in front and eating from the bar menu. We were lucky and had a wonderful experience twice. I left one of my cherished jackets at the restaurant and didn’t realize it until we left Islamorada. One of the managers, Sandra, was kind enough to take the time to mail my jacket back to me even though it was one of the busiest times of the year for the restaurant. Beautiful food, setting, sunset and lovely people. read less

4/21/2021

We had planned to sit outside but the late April sun still shone too hot so we opted for the... read moreWe had planned to sit outside but the late April sun still shone too hot so we opted for the couch at the far side of Pierre's bar, beneath the canoe artfully perched on the wall. The drinks were varied and sublime but soon it was time to move upstairs to the balcony for our dinner. The sun shades adjusted to keep the heat down, we settled in for one more cocktail, and a bottle of Shafer cab. The onion soup? Excellent and hot enough to make me forget the sun. The foie gras? My table mates raved. It's not pate, it's the actual liver so you're getting the real thing. If you're unfamiliar with sous vide cooking, learn how the experts do it by ordering the veal cheeks. Triple tail was on the menu so two of us ventured there to great acclaim. The place is expensive but they deliver value. As the sun set, the shades went up, the breeze came alive and the view through the palms made the setting perfect. I'm hard to impress. I was impressed. My only regret? The party of four celebrating a birthday at an adjacent table failed to offer us a slice of their cake even though we sang along. Oh, well. read less

4/19/2021

From its fantastic location to its beautiful building to its excellent service to its exceptional cocktails to its sublime and... read moreFrom its fantastic location to its beautiful building to its excellent service to its exceptional cocktails to its sublime and amazing food, a must for anyone looking for a fine dining experience in the Keys. read less

4/13/2021

We went on Easter. They had a fixed menu with three entrees for a set price of $120 each. This... read moreWe went on Easter. They had a fixed menu with three entrees for a set price of $120 each. This wasn’t advertised even they confirmed that. When asked if we can order from their regular menu the answer was this is the only menu. Gratuity was included although it was scratched out on the receipt. We had two kids with us and although they had a kids menu it wasn’t offered to us. Probably because the waitress wanted the $240 for the kids so her tip that was included would be much higher than if she had given us the kids menu. The food was ok at best. The table behind us was obnoxious loud fighting, crying, using foul language. The waitress didn’t offer to move us or them. When asked about the tip being scratched out that was by mistake. They are trying to take advantage of people on vacation knowing they won’t be coming back. I called three times asking for a manager to call me. No one has. Please don’t fall in the same trap we did. read less

4/13/2021

What a wonderful evening! We started out on the porch to get a great view of the sunset, but a... read moreWhat a wonderful evening! We started out on the porch to get a great view of the sunset, but a storm came up and we moved inside. Ellen Grace (our server) is a consummate professional. Totally unflustered by the near-hurricane brewing, she whisked us inside without missing a beat and our fabulous meal continued uninterrupted. The soft shell crab app, French onion soup, and duck breast entree were all wonderful. My only criticism of the night was that the pork chop special I ordered was 50% more costly than any other entree. If that’s the case, I think the price should be mentioned when listing the specials. Otherwise a perfect dining experience that shouldn’t be missed in Islamorada. Still the best view of the sunset in town! read less

4/11/2021

We went to Pierre’s last night .. the service was so slooooooow .. beautiful views .. food was ok but... read moreWe went to Pierre’s last night .. the service was so slooooooow .. beautiful views .. food was ok but not worth the time or the price. We had 6 people and it was over 3 hours.
Our waiter was absent most of the time..
octopus was very salty and the Buffalo mozzarella was so so..
Although the bread and olive oil was fabulous.. but again not a 5 star or one I would not go again. read less

4/11/2021

The setting at the lovely Pierres restaurant is fabulous. Skylar who was the seating hostess made sure we were comfortably... read moreThe setting at the lovely Pierres restaurant is fabulous. Skylar who was the seating hostess made sure we were comfortably seated at a shaded outdoor table. We enjoyed our meal. The onion soup was especially memorable. Perhaps we were naive but when we were seated we were offered a choice of still or bubbly water. We chose still thinking this was regular water. No--on our bill was an $8.00 charge. We should have said "regular" even though that was not one of the choices. We feel they took advantage, so watch out unless you want $8.00 water. read less

4/10/2021

You cannot beat this location for (in no certain order) a) indoor decor; b) outdoor seating area; c) cocktails and... read moreYou cannot beat this location for (in no certain order) a) indoor decor; b) outdoor seating area; c) cocktails and d) the FOOD. This place has almost (see below) everything going for it. The food is the star and should be the reason you come here, above all else...it is spectacular. Our party tried four different appetizers from the foie gras to the octopus and all were spectacular. Our entrees were equally fantastic, from the veal chop special to the curried lobster (not many dishes are presented with half a coconut on the plate!). We all marveled at the meal and enjoyed both the indoor and outdoor spaces. This is quite the place and a must-stop for a foodie!
The only negative was a wine list that seemed to scream...look how expensive these wines are instead of look what a great wine list we have. That being said, there are some gems on it... read less

4/05/2021

Beautiful place. Outside seating on the beach to watch the sunset is nice and wait staff was good. However...we were... read moreBeautiful place. Outside seating on the beach to watch the sunset is nice and wait staff was good. However...we were then seated inside at a back table with no view. They had asked if it was a special occasion and we said yes an anniversary. Waiter took our orders and appetizers were good. Dinner was less than mediocre ...fish...supposed to be snapper but we really could not tell as it was totally dried out and tasteless. Scallops were good but very overpriced for what you get. When we ask for the chef or manager, we were told they were busy but to wait, and did we want dessert? We saw the chef chatting with other customers and decided to leave. Way too pricey for lousy food. read less

3/25/2021

We were happy to get a reservation for a table outside on the porch. From there we had a perfect... read moreWe were happy to get a reservation for a table outside on the porch. From there we had a perfect view of the sun setting. Our great meal started with a cocktail (rum punch $15). My husband and I split the butter lettuce salad with pistachios and each had a sufficient amount. Then our main course - lobster tail with a curry sauce, bok choi and purple rice - out of this world. We followed our mail course with strawberry gelato and fresh strawberries.
The only drawback about this restaurant is that it is a bit pricey. read less

3/25/2021

Waited a while for initial service, ordered cocktails. Asked for bread. Much later ordered our appetizers along with the main... read moreWaited a while for initial service, ordered cocktails. Asked for bread. Much later ordered our appetizers along with the main course and wine. Appetizers arrived first, immediately followed by entree. Bread and wine showed up much later. Fresh catch was very overcooked, lobster dry as a bone and chewy. Service staff not at all consistent for a high end restaurant. Was visited by a manager (not sure, he didn’t introduce by his title). When I said the food was “just ok”, he left. Wouldn’t recommend this place. read less

3/22/2021

Delicious food, beautiful atmosphere and an all around top favorite of our trip! This is a must when dining in islamorada!

3/20/2021

I would start by saying that it’s hard for me to complain- because the truth is that I have a... read moreI would start by saying that it’s hard for me to complain- because the truth is that I have a lot to be thankful for. But it is also true that my family and I were treated very badly indeed by Pierre’s. Rude, indifferent service and a very long and discourteous wait. And the response we got when we expressed concern about how long after our reservation we had waited without being seated (that they are so popular and cannot control how much people like their restaurant) seemed to verify their attitude- especially as we watched several other parties be seated ahead of us despite having a later reservation. There are many fine restaurants in the world- but none I have experienced has used their reputation, history of fine dining, or beautiful views as a means of justifying ill treatment of its current guests. Rather- in my experience these establishments manage their bookings and times as carefully as they do their kitchen. Not so at Pierre’s. The manager badly needs a course in customer relations... I would suggest that informing dissatisfied guests that you never guaranteed them good service when they complain that they have received poor service is not a successful long term strategy. We drove 45 minutes and left without eating, feeling like we were not welcome because of our name. I would rather eat a $5 cheeseburger and be treated well than pay what I would have at Pierre’s to be treated that way. Shame on them. read less

3/16/2021

A very memorable restaurant experience: we had the salmon and the scallops, which were both prepared perfectly with delicious sauces... read moreA very memorable restaurant experience: we had the salmon and the scallops, which were both prepared perfectly with delicious sauces and flavors in the accompanying sides. The house salad was great too. Our waitress, Ellen Grace, was superb and she is highly recommended. The other staff were very helpful and courteous too. read less

3/15/2021

This restaurant really exceeded my expectations. We arrived about 90 minutes ahead of our reservation time to watch the sunset.... read moreThis restaurant really exceeded my expectations. We arrived about 90 minutes ahead of our reservation time to watch the sunset. The outdoor lounge are is perfectly lovely. They have little fire pits at several of the couches and it was so cozy and inviting. Service was great.
The restaurant itself is such a beautiful old building and the inside bar and lounge is old school classy. I loved it.
We were seated on the upper balcony right on the water. The views are amazing. This coming from a life long Floridian who has visited many Caribbean locations.
The food and presentation was beautiful. We had several different appetizers and lobster curry. It was a bit eclectic with an interesting mix of flavors. Desserts were unfortunately underwhelming but everything else made up for it. Highly recommend this upscale causal restaurant if you are visiting Islamorada. read less

3/14/2021