test

What a surprise to find elegant dining at the beach! Although I had to tell our lovely serving person, Ellen... read moreWhat a surprise to find elegant dining at the beach! Although I had to tell our lovely serving person, Ellen Grace, how to make a regular Daiquiri (non frozen) ,she made one perfectly. Our meals was unique and delicious. And you cannot beat the gracious surroundings! read less

2/28/2021

We had a great meal. Tuna tartare appetizer, local catch, and a bottle of wine. Kids ate off the kids... read moreWe had a great meal. Tuna tartare appetizer, local catch, and a bottle of wine. Kids ate off the kids menu. Our server Ellen Grace was fantastic and recommended an Oregon Pinot that was perfect. Would recommend this for food, atmosphere and service. read less

2/21/2021

Very rude staff - especially the manager and hostess. We had a gift certificate for $150 which at first they... read moreVery rude staff - especially the manager and hostess. We had a gift certificate for $150 which at first they would not accept. After three attempts, we asked to speak to the manager. He literally walked away from us when we tried to talk to him. They finally accepted it. The food was marginal and WAY overpriced. The bill was $210 for 2 drinks, 2 entrees and 2 glasses of wine. My "fish of the day" was overcooked and quite dry. Little or no seasoning on much of the food. Would not recommend it at all. Too many other good restaurants on the Keys! read less

2/17/2021

For delicious food atmosphere &staff. Multi level Plantation style home set amidst perfect lighting and ambiance. It’s located right on... read moreFor delicious food atmosphere &staff. Multi level Plantation style home set amidst perfect lighting and ambiance. It’s located right on the beach close to the calm ocean with patio and indoor seating. We started our meal with foie gras n ended with a dul che de leche dessert. Absolutely perfect!!! 10/10 read less

2/15/2021

The online menu doesn't match the live one so don't get your taste buds set for the online menu, big... read moreThe online menu doesn't match the live one so don't get your taste buds set for the online menu, big disappointment when you want something that isn't there. read less

2/13/2021

Beautiful view, Great service and great food. Went before dinner to the back lounge area directly on the beach and... read moreBeautiful view, Great service and great food. Went before dinner to the back lounge area directly on the beach and had great drinks with music playing and even a fire which was convenient because it was a cool night read less

2/10/2021

Great ambiance and location on the water. While the prices are high, our meals were absolutely incredible. The service was... read moreGreat ambiance and location on the water. While the prices are high, our meals were absolutely incredible. The service was also great. Highly recommend for a romantic dinner. read less

1/24/2021

Great food but the service was less than stellar. The server never asked if we wanted another drink even though... read moreGreat food but the service was less than stellar. The server never asked if we wanted another drink even though he picked up our empty glasses. Nerve came back to check on our food or how we liked it.
The food was outstanding, the experience disappointed. read less

1/17/2021

Dinner served in a old plantation house. Decor was pleasant. Service was good but not the greatest. The lighting was... read moreDinner served in a old plantation house. Decor was pleasant. Service was good but not the greatest. The lighting was very dim. Saw a woman eating her food by flashlight. All in all, it was a wonderful fine dining experience. read less

1/04/2021

The restaurant is in a wonderful spot and great for a pre dinner drink on the beach. All of our... read moreThe restaurant is in a wonderful spot and great for a pre dinner drink on the beach. All of our food was superb and good portions . Our waitress was very helpful and knowledgeable, we will definitely return next time we are in Islamorada . read less

1/01/2021

Don’t expect to see your server after he had taken your order. We had to get the attention of another... read moreDon’t expect to see your server after he had taken your order. We had to get the attention of another server to bring pepper to our table which arrived after 3/4 of the meal was eaten.Don’t expect the wine you to arrive when dinner arrives- you need to get the attention of someone to bring it. Don’t expect a wine chiller to arrive with the white wine you ordered-again we had to get the attention of another waiter to bring a chiller. You are then on your own filling your wine glasses.
Short ribs and scallop dish was over cooked. We had made another reservation to return Pierres later this week but based on our experience we will not be returning. read less

11/27/2020

I made a reservation for Thanksgiving for the 5 of us back in October. When we arrived in Islamorada I... read moreI made a reservation for Thanksgiving for the 5 of us back in October. When we arrived in Islamorada I called to confirm and they told me they didn’t have our reservation but they would check and call me back. The first girl said “the other girl doesn’t always put things in the computer. “ Well nobody called me back so when I followed up the “manager” said “parties of 6 or more had to leave a credit card deposit so they cancelled our reservation .” Well first we were 5 and secondly nobody asked me for a card- which I gladly would have provided. Now it is Thanksgiving Andre have no place to eat. Thanks Pierre’s for ruining a special time for us! read less

11/26/2020

We were staying at Cheeca but had my birthday dinner at Pierre's. The cheese and charcutiere platter appetizer was outstanding.... read moreWe were staying at Cheeca but had my birthday dinner at Pierre's. The cheese and charcutiere platter appetizer was outstanding. Wonderful service. My fish was a little over cooked but delicious. We are returning for my wife's birthday next week. Also purchased a gift certificate for a co-workers birthday so she and her husband could experience a memorable dinner. read less

11/25/2020

wanted to eat inside with fine dining. Tired of outdoor bar food and Jimmy Buffet music On line menu looked... read morewanted to eat inside with fine dining. Tired of outdoor bar food and Jimmy Buffet music On line menu looked great . Plenty of our favorite French dishes. Went inside and took elevator to second floor. Decor and ambiance wonderful French Moroccan
Service very attentive . Ordered Aperol Spritz for wife dirty martini up for me Looked at menue and was not what was on web site. No onion soup What French restaurant doesnt have onion soup? No steak tartar, no sweet breads. Nothing on menue turned us on. Specials were two fish dishes again no thanks, venison which sounded good until i was told $ 60 and some kind of steak for $90. Settled on Charcuterie for $ 30 a plate of thinly sliced cold cuts. Left $75 poorer. Ive eaten in the finest in San Francisco, Chicago, N Y and Paris. This doesnt campare read less

11/19/2020

Food caliber was average and extremely overpriced. Key lime pie looked like it was purchased from local grocery store. Also... read moreFood caliber was average and extremely overpriced. Key lime pie looked like it was purchased from local grocery store. Also we were jammed together outside when there was plenty of room to provide social distancing. read less

11/14/2020